SeylumaThe journalExplore readings
The journal Your relationship

The second square of chocolate

Daria knew how this story ended. That was becoming a problem for its beginning.

An illustration of two people talking across a café table in the afternoon

Daria gave him the second square of chocolate before he'd asked. It came beside her coffee, and she didn't particularly want to share it. Eli thanked her and broke it in half. She watched him push a piece back across the saucer.

It was their fifth date. He had a habit of asking small, exact questions. Which film had she actually liked? Did she want to walk or sit down? She found herself answering with whatever sounded easiest to accommodate.

Afterward she would wonder whether they were compatible, as if her preferences had been part of the evidence.

Her last relationship had made being undemanding feel useful. With Eli she was already trying to become indispensable before either had decided what they wanted. An open afternoon felt like a chance she must accept. A difference in taste felt like something she should smooth over.

She'd brought three recent encounters to her tarot question. A museum afternoon she enjoyed, a late dinner she'd accepted despite an early shift, and a film she'd said she loved because he did.

She liked his curiosity and his terrible impressions of the gallery audio guide. Those were details about him. Her wish to be chosen was a different part of the story.

Ace of Cups, illustrated by Pamela Colman Smith
Ace of Cups
Seven of Pentacles, illustrated by Pamela Colman Smith
Seven of Pentacles
Temperance, illustrated by Pamela Colman Smith
Temperance

Ace of CupsWater overflows the offered cup. The Ace could give the pleasure of a beginning room without turning a fifth date into a declaration about the relationship's future.

Seven of PentaclesThe gardener pauses beside growing fruit. The image could suggest learning through repeated encounters, including moments when Daria let a real preference become visible.

TemperanceWater moves between two cups without either being emptied. Here, balance could mean keeping her existing life while allowing this connection to find its place within it.

The interpretation hadn't made her feelings smaller. It had asked her to notice what she was already trading for the imagined security of being easy. There was warmth in the connection. There was also a person Eli hadn't had much chance to meet: Daria when she wanted something inconvenient.

Now he asked whether she could meet on Thursday. She had a ceramics class. Her bowls still leaned to one side, but she'd spent six weeks learning to center clay and wanted to keep going. She nearly said she could miss one session. Instead she told him about the jug she'd been trying to finish.

Eli asked what made the jug difficult. She described attaching the handle twice, then suggested Saturday afternoon. The conversation continued. Her refusal hadn't revealed his entire character or settled their compatibility.

It had given them a little more actual experience of one another, which was what she'd been skipping whenever she anticipated the most agreeable answer.

On Saturday they visited a bookshop. He picked a novel she'd already read and disliked. She told him why. They argued cheerfully about the ending until the bookseller asked whether either intended to buy it. Daria bought a different book.

Eli carried his choice to the till, still unconvinced, and she found she wanted to hear what he'd think when he'd finished.

More stories

The question in the wrong box

Finding your question

What had grown in eighteen months.

How they see you